Sunday, April 12, 2009

The Inescapable Story of Easter

Via Ross Douthat (again) a John Updike poem on Easter -- here is a sample:
Let us not mock God with metaphor,
Analogy, sidestepping, transcendence,
Making of the event a parable, a sign painted in the faded
Credulity of earlier ages:
Let us walk through the door.

The stone is rolled back, not papier-mache,
Not a stone in a story,
But the vast rock of materiality that in the slow grinding of
Time will eclipse for each of us
The wide light of day.
I remember hearing a Mennonite pastor telling the story of his dying mother, a simple Russian immigrant approaching death seeing Jesus at the foot of her bed. He took this to be a hallucination symbolic of her deep faith -- and nothing else. As Updike reminds us, this not only misses the point, it "mocks God."

Saturday, April 11, 2009

A Guru We Can Believe In?

Via Paul Krugman and Justin Lahart of the WSJ -- a thirty year old reminder of the vacuousness of economic punditry in this springtime of "green shoots" and other mindless optimism. Enjoy.

Bill Blakey, the Social Gospel and the Justice Tradition

As I write, CBC's The House is discussing the role of faith in politics. The first interview, however, is by far the more interesting. Bill Blakey talks about his faith grounded in the social gospel that was the foundation of the early CCF and NDP. The rest of the show looks at the role of a more evangelical faith in politics. The contrast could not be more stark.

Have a listen.

Those Pesky Accounting Standards -- Now Europe

The Economist reports today that the IASB, the body that regulates accounting standards in Europe is under political pressure to loosen fair-value accounting standards, particularly those known as "mark to market". We have, of course, already seen this in Canada and the U.S.. As the Economist describes it
On April 2nd, after a bruising encounter with Congress, America’s Financial Accounting Standards Board (FASB) rushed through rule changes. These gave banks more freedom to use models to value illiquid assets and more flexibility in recognising losses on long-term assets in their income statements. Bob Herz, the FASB’s chairman, decried those who “impugn our motives”. Yet bank shares rose and the changes enhance what one lobbying group politely calls “

European ministers instantly demanded that the International Accounting Standards Board (IASB) do likewise. The IASB says it does not want to be “piecemeal”, but the pressure to fold when it completes its overhaul of rules later this year is strong. On April 1st Charlie McCreevy, a European commissioner, warned the IASB that it did “not live in a political vacuum” but “in the real world” and that Europe could yet develop different rules.

So the rules change, and as this weeks experience shows, banks achieve instant profitability and are suddenly able to fully participate in credit markets. Isn't accounting fun! A stroke of the pen moves them from insolvency to darling of the market! (Warning: don't try this at home.)

Banks worldwide have suggested fair-value proponents are on the wrong planet. However, the Economist throws its considerable weight behind the argument that
[i]t was banks that were on the wrong planet, with accounts that vastly overvalued assets. Today they argue that market prices overstate losses, because they largely reflect the temporary illiquidity of markets, not the likely extent of bad debts. The truth will not be known for years. But banks’ shares trade below their book value, suggesting that investors are sceptical. And dead markets partly reflect the paralysis of banks which will not sell assets for fear of booking losses, yet are reluctant to buy all those supposed bargains.

Friday, April 10, 2009

More From Douthat

For Good Friday, and uncompromising and provocative understanding of the Gospel message by Terry Eagleton in Reason, Faith and Revolution. I have ordered the book!
... for Christian teaching, God's love and forgiveness are ruthlessly unforgiving powers which break violently into our protective, self-rationalizing little sphere, smashing our sentimental illusions and turning our world brutally upside down. In Jesus, the law is revealed to be the law of love and mercy, and God not some Blakean Nobodaddy but a helpless, vulnerable animal. It is the flayed and bloody scapegoat of Calvary that is now the true signifier of the law
... Here, then, is your pie in the sky or opium of the people, your soft-eyed consolation and pale-cheeked piety. Here is the fantasy and escapism that the hard-headed secularist pragmatist finds so distasteful. Freud saw religion as the mitigation of the harshness of the human condition; but it would surely be at least as plausible to claim that what we call reality is a mitigation of the Gospel's ruthless demands, which include such agreeable acts of escapism as being ready to lay down your life for a total stranger. Imitating Jesus means imitating his death as well as his life, since the two are not finally distinguishable. The death is the consummation of the life, the place where the ultimate meaning of Jesus's self-giving is revealed.

... What is at stake here is not a prudently reformist project of pouring new wine into old bottles, but an avant-gardist epiphany of the absolutely new - of a regime so revolutionary as to surpass all image and utterance, a reign of justice and fellowship which for the Gospel writers is even now striking into this bankrupt, dépassé, washed-up world ... The coming of the kingdom involves not a change of government, but a turbulent passage through death, nothingness, madness, loss and futility ... signified among other things by Christ's descent into hell after his death. There is no possiblity of a smooth evolution here. Given the twisted state of the world, self-fulfillment can ultimately come about only through self-divestment.
This view, that the institutional church has perverted the Gospel message, can also be found in Jacques Ellul's The Subversion of Christianity and in Ivan Illich and David Cayley's The Rivers North of the Future. A large collection of Ellul's writings can be found in the theology section of the Jesus Radicals site.

No Limits to Medicine Here!

on BoingBoing asks what medical procedure is being applied by this medic.

My question is whether it is covered by the NHS.

Those Amazing, Magic Bank Profits -- II

From Floyd Norris of the NYT. Barclays Bank has discovered another route to instant profitability -- make a loan to yourself! Oh those clever banks.

As Norris describes it:

Barclays, the large British institution, announced a $3.1 billion loan today. And it also promised to keep the loan on its own balance sheet for a year, rather than sell off parts of it to other banks. Even after the year is up, it promises to keep most of the loan.

And who will get the cash from that loan? Barclays itself. It will also be able to report a large profit, of $2.2 billion, which is something every bank needs these days. And Robert E. Diamond, Barclays’ president, stands to take home $6.9 million of the money.

Barclays is selling its iShares business, which puts together exchange-traded funds, to a private equity firm for $4.4 billion, and financing the deal itself. So the cash stays right where it is, but a profit is posted. Mr. Diamond owns a stake in the business, so he gets to share in the bounty. (The bank says he was not involved in the negotiations.)

As with their American cousins, shares leaped on this news. One begins to feel less and less sorry for bank shareholders.

Douthat on Good Friday

Ross Douthat passes along somc excerpts from an article by Rene Girard in First Things. (ht Andrew Sullivan.) I cannot possibly improve on this, so I pass it along in its entirety.
Beginning with the story of Cain and Abel, the Bible proclaims the innocence of mythical victims and the guilt of their victimizers. Living after the widespread promulgation of the gospel, we find this natural and never pause to think that in classical myths the opposite is true: the persecutors always seem to have a valid cause to persecute their victims. The Dionysiac myths regard even the most horrible lynchings as legitimate. Pentheus in the Bacchae is legitimately slain by his mother and sisters, for his contempt of the god Dionysus is a fault serious enough to warrant his death. Oedipus, too, deserves his fate. According to the myth, he has truly killed his father and married his mother, and is thus truly responsible for the plague that ravages Thebes. To cast him out is not merely a permissible action, but a religious duty ...

This interpretation is reinforced by the optimistic endings of myths. The conjunction of the guilty victim and the reconciled community is too frequent to be fortuitous. The only possible explanation is the distorted representation of unanimous victimization. The violent process is not effective unless it fools all witnesses, and the proof that it does, in the case of myths, is the harmonious and cathartic conclusion, rooted in a perfectly unanimous murder.

...

Instead of blaming victimization on the victims, the Gospels blame it on the victimizers. What the myths systematically hide, the Bible reveals ... The false or insignificant causes of mythical violence are effectively dismissed in the simple and sweeping statement, They hated me without a cause (John 15:25), in which Jesus quotes and virtually summarizes Psalm 35--one of the "scapegoat psalms" that literally turns the mob's mythical justifications inside out. Instead of the mob speaking to justify violence with causes that it perceives as legitimate, the victim speaks to denounce the causes as nonexistent ...

The true Resurrection is based not on the mythical lie of the guilty victim who deserves to die, but on the rectification of that lie, which comes from the true God and which reopens channels of communication mankind itself had closed through self-imprisonment in its own violent cultures. Divine grace alone can explain why, after the Resurrection, the disciples could become a dissenting minority in an ocean of victimization--could understand then what they had misunderstood earlier: the innocence not of Jesus alone but of all victims of all Passion-like murders since the foundation of the world.

Homesteading in Suburbia -- Meet the Bandos

The New York Times has a piece today on what must be one of the more interesting trends to come out of the mortgage finance and housing crisis in the U.S. -- formerly homeless people taking informal and illegal possession of abandoned homes.
When the woman who calls herself Queen Omega moved into a three-bedroom house here last December, she introduced herself to the neighbors, signed contracts for electricity and water and ordered an Internet connection.

What she did not tell anyone was that she had no legal right to tbe in the home.

Ms. Omega, 48, is one of the beneficiaries of the foreclosure crisis. Through a small advocacy group of local volunteers called Take Back the Land, she moved from a friend’s couch into a newly empty house that sold just a few years ago for more than $400,000.

Michael Stoops, executive director of the National Coalition for the Homeless, said about a dozen advocacy groups around the country were actively moving homeless people into vacant homes — some working in secret, others, like Take Back the Land, operating openly.
So not only are squatters moving in, but advocacy groups are assisting them. This is certainly an interesting (and defensible?) twist on the self-help ethos.

Workers in Hard Times

I have been re-reading Harry Braverman's Labor and Monopoly Capital. In the introduction he talks about the soul-deadening nature of assembly line work, especially in the auto industry. It occurs to me that perhaps the best statement ever made on this is Charlie Chaplin's Modern Times, made in 1936 in the depths of the depression. Here is a clip


Crazy Chaplin Screwing Up Everything - Modern Times - A funny movie is a click away

A treat for the holiday. Enjoy!