Monday, April 13, 2009

Continuing Pressure on the Drug War Front

How much longer can the insane war on drugs continue? . This morning's Financial Times asks and answers the question this way

How much misery can a policy cause before it is acknowledged as a failure and reversed? The US “war on drugs” suggests there is no upper limit. The country’s implacable blend of prohibition and punitive criminal justice is wrong-headed in every way: immoral in principle, since it prosecutes victimless crimes, and in practice a disaster of remarkable proportions. Yet for a US politician to suggest wholesale reform of this brainless regime is still seen as an act of reckless self-harm.

Even a casual observer can see that much of the damage done in the US by illegal drugs is a result of the fact that they are illegal, not the fact that they are drugs. Vastly more lives are blighted by the brutality of prohibition, and by the enormous criminal networks it has created, than by the substances themselves. This is true of cocaine and heroin as well as of soft drugs such as marijuana. But the assault on consumption of marijuana sets the standard for the policy’s stupidity.

Nearly half of all Americans say they have tried marijuana. That makes them criminals in the eyes of the law. Luckily, not all of them have been found out – but when one is grateful that most law-breakers go undetected, there is something wrong with the law.

Recently many commentators have noted that Portugal has shown a way out of this mess. It has decriminalized the entire range of street drugs for personal use. Not surprisingly, criminality and violence have decline. But so to has drug use. Go figure.

Canada has a role to play here. It is clear that the U.S. is too stuck on this "war" to ever change on its own. We, however, suffer disproportionately from spillovers from American policy. Though the hapless Harper government is behind the curve on this and so many other issues, it would be good to hear some encouraging words from the Liberal government in waiting.

GM and Manufacturing in Ontario

From Calculated Risk this morning, it is looking more and more like GM is headed for court protection in the U.S. by June 1. It cites the NYT which says that
The Treasury Department is directing General Motors to lay the groundwork for a bankruptcy filing by a June 1 deadline, despite G.M.’s public contention that it could still reorganize outside court, people with knowledge of the plans said during the weekend. ...

The goal is to prepare for a fast “surgical” bankruptcy, the people who had been briefed on the plans said. G.M., which has been granted $13.4 billion in federal aid, insists that a quick restructuring is necessary so its image and sales are not damaged permanently.

The preparations are aimed at assuring a G.M. bankruptcy filing is ready should the company be unable to reach agreement with bondholders to exchange roughly $28 billion in debt into equity in G.M. and with the United Automobile Workers union, which has balked at granting concessions without sacrifices from bondholders.
Meanwhile, in Ontario, both GM workers and pensioners and parts manufacturers face potentially devastating losses if bankruptcy proceeds. No one has stepped up to guarantee pensions, parts manufacturers have staggering receivables exposures and there is little sense of how court procedures in Canada and the U.S. would mesh.

In other words, we hit the wall in seven weeks, and very few in Canada seem to be turning their minds to what this might mean and what the policy response might be. Rather, in true Canadian fashion we seem to be turning this into another opportunity for a federal-provincial showdown.

Sunday, April 12, 2009

Nanoblogging -- the Next Level

ht Andrew Sullivan -- some more holiday fun

Its Only Paranoia if you're Wrong

A little treat for the Holiday

Annoy Charlie Smith Inc. -- Trailer #1


Annoy Charlie Smith Inc- Trailer from Seaton Smith on Vimeo.

. . . and Trailer #2


Annoy Charlie Smith Inc trailer 2 from Seaton Smith on Vimeo.

Enjoy!

Eisenhower and Peace


From the 100 Days blog at the NYT, some thoughts on what we might learn from Eisenhower's approach to Korea.

Before his nomination he visited Korea, and while he had campaigned on victory and unification, he returned convinced that peace negotiations were the only realistic approach. As Jean Edward Smith tells it
Ike spent three days in Korea. He conferred with his old friends, Gen. Mark Clark and Gen. James Van Fleet, talked to division and regimental commanders, and ate C-rations at the front with G.I.’s from the 15th Infantry — Eisenhower’s old regiment. Most significantly, he flew along the battle line, roughly the 38th Parallel, in an artillery observation plane (the military equivalent of a Piper Cub) for a good look at the terrain . . .[and] he returned to the United States determined to make peace.
It is particularly telling the Ike pursued peace over the heads of his most senior advisors as well as leaders in congress. In a speach where he made his intentions public, he declared
Every gun that is fired, every warship launched, every rocket fired signifies a theft from those who hunger and are not fed, those who are cold and are notclothed….A world that begins to witness the rebirth of trust among nations can find its way to a peace that is neither partial nor punitive…. The first great step along this way must be the conclusion of an honorable armistice in Korea.
A particularly poignant sentiment for Easter Sunday. Because he had experienced the true horrors of war, Eisenhower was able to understand the precious value of peace and pursued it tenaciously despite opposition. When peace was achieved, quite quickly as it turned out,
Eisenhower ignored the criticism. “The war is over,” he told press secretary James Hagerty. “I hope my son is going to come home soon.”
Would that our Canadian generals' bellicose statements in the lead up to the Afghan mission have been tempered by the same understanding and compassion.

The End of the Culture Wars?


So James Dobson, of Focus on the Family fame, has conceded defeat in the culture wars. And the principle reason for this? A President who has been out of power for more than eight years.

This is surely wonderful news for Christians and the Church. Freed of Constantinian theocratic pretensions, we are much freer to be what we were always meant to be: the presence of Christ in the world -- not the United States at prayer and not a wing of the Republican Party and not neo-pharisees.

Dobson's strategy in the so-called culture wars has always seemed to me to be one of judgment and hatred couched in Orwellian newspeak. It seemed diametrically opposed to the love and acceptance preached and lived by Jesus in his life, death and resurrection and by the early Church. Christ did not judge sinners, but rather those who judged sinners themselves. The Pharisees, the most righteous of people, were his principle target. One wonders how kindly He would judge Dr. Dobson.

Dobson believes that the Church and Christians must fight on. But perhaps God's message here is that we have been fundamentally misguided and that we need to radically redirect our efforts.

Anyways, here it is from the horse's mouth, so to speak


The Rt. Hon. Tub of Lard?


Paul Krugman gets nasty!

Last hour on his blog, Krugman posted regrets that he did not get to meet with Rick Warren this morning on This Week. Or as he put it
So I was all ready to talk about Rick Warren on today’s panel, only to learn that he had cancelled out at the last minute. The show replaced him with pirates, plus an extended roundtable. But I think they should have done what the British show Have I Got News For You did when a guest failed to show: they replaced him with a tub of lard, addressed throughout the show as the Rt. Hon. Tub of Lard.
Way to go, Prof. Krugman!

And what is making Krugman so fiesty? Perhaps it is just that this doesn't appear to be a routine cancellation. Politico reports that
Pastor Rick Warren, after making apparently contradictory statements about his stance on a gay-marriage measure, canceled an Easter Sunday appearance on ABC’s “This Week” just “moments before the scheduled interview,” host George Stephanopoulos told viewers.

Stephanopoulos said Warren’s representatives said the best-selling evangelical author was “sick with exhaustion.” The host told viewers that he wished the pastor a speedy recovery.

Warren’s appearance would have given him the chance to clear up his claim last week on CNN’s “Larry King Live” that he “never once … gave an endorsement” to California’s Proposition 8, a successful November ballot measure that banned gay marriage in the nation’s largest state.


Here is the clip



No equivocation here. So no edorsement? Here it is



Happy Easter Pastor Rick!

Henry Mintzberg on Managing Our Way into Crisis


As I write this, CBC's Sunday Edition is airing an interview with Henry Mintzberg. Mintzberg, Canada's leading management academic, is arguing that our current crisis is one of management and not economics, and that in particular it is a product of the failure of business schools to adequately equip the current management cadre with the tools for effective leadership.

(In its usual elitist fashion, the host, Michael Enright, has posted no links to or references for Mintzberg's work. Nor is there a podcast. What can we expect for a paltry multibillion dollar budget.)

Much of the thrust of Mintzberg's argument can be found in a recent Globe & Mail opionion piece entitled America's Monumental Failure of Management. He summarizes his argument as follows:

We call this a financial crisis or an economic one, but, at the core, it is a crisis of management. To understand this, consider the mortgage debacle.

How could these mortgages have come to exist in the first place and, worse, how could they have spread to so many of the bluest of blue-chip financial institutions? The answers seem readily apparent. Those who promoted these mortgages were intent on driving up sales as quickly as possible for the benefit of their own bonuses, the ultimate consequences be damned. In fact, they sold off these mortgages as quickly possible.

But how could any serious financial institution have bought this junk - or, more to the point, tolerated a culture of people too lazy or disinterested to realize it was junk? That, too, is simple: These companies were not being managed. They were being "led" - heroically, no doubt - for short-term spectacular performance. The executives didn't know, and the employees didn't care.

What we have here is a monumental failure of management. American management is still revered across much of the globe for what it used to be. Now, a great deal of it is just plain rotten - detached and hubristic. Instead of rolling up their sleeves and getting engaged, too many CEOs sit in their offices and deem: They pronounce targets for others to meet, or else get fired.

And he follows this by laying the blame for management failure squarely at the feet of managment schools, particularly the elite schools:

Management is a practice, learned in context. No manager, let alone leader, has ever been created in a classroom. Programs that claim to do so promote hubris instead. And that has been carried from the business schools into corporate America on a massive scale.

Harvard Business School, according to its MBA website, is "focused on one purpose - developing leaders." At Harvard, you become such a leader by reading hundreds of brief case studies, each the day before you or your colleagues are called on to pronounce on what that company should do. Yesterday, you knew nothing about Acme Inc.; today, you're pretending to decide its future. What kind of leader does that create?

Harvard prides itself on how many of its graduates make it to the executive suites. Learning how to present arguments in a classroom certainly helps. But how do these people perform once they get to those suites? Harvard does not ask. So we took a look.

Joseph Lampel and I found a list of Harvard Business School superstars, published in a 1990 book by a long-term insider. We tracked the performance of the 19 corporate chief executives on that list, many of them famous, across more than a decade. Ten were outright failures (the company went bankrupt, the CEO was fired, a major merger backfired etc.); another four had questionable records at best. Five out of the 19 seemed to do fine. These figures, limited as they were, sounded pretty damning. (When we published our results, there was nary a peep. No one really cared.)

In other words, as Mintzberg demonstrates in this video, the leadership function of management is not, and cannot be something that is effectively taught out of context in business schools. And to the extent that we draw elites from these schools they will not only be fallibe but both hubristic and excessively error prone.

Piracy as Insurgency

Robert Kaplan has an interesting piece on Piracy in today's NYT. For him, this anarchy at sea is a direct result of anarchy on land. And Somalia, along whose coast this is occuring, is the ultimate failed anarchic state.

Piracy, of course, has the potential to disrupt major trade routes and hence trade at the same time that global trade is under assault from protectionist reactions to the economic crisis. Kaplan suggests, however, that the assymetric nature of piracy represents a greater threat -- its potential use as a terrorist weapon:
The big danger in our day is that piracy can potentially serve as a platform for terrorists. Using pirate techniques, vessels can be hijacked and blown up in the middle of a crowded strait, or a cruise ship seized and the passengers of certain nationalities thrown overboard. You can see how Al Qaeda would be studying this latest episode at sea, in which Somali pirates attacked a Maersk Line container ship and were fought off by the American crew, even as they have managed to take the captain hostage in one of the lifeboats.
The obvious response to this is military (in this case, naval) interdiction. Yet as Kaplan notes, this presents the usual problems of a massively powerful response to asymmetric attacks:
So we end up with the spectacle of an American destroyer, the Bainbridge, with enough Tomahawk missiles and other weaponry to destroy a small city, facing off against a handful of Somali pirates in a tiny lifeboat. This is not an efficient use of American resources. It indicates how pirates, like terrorists, can attack us asymmetrically. The challenge ahead for the United States is not only dealing with the rise of Chinese naval power, but also in handling more unconventional risks that will require a more scrappy, street-fighting Navy.
Sadly, however, this overlooks a half century of lessons on asymmetric warfare. As both the recent groundbreaking work of the U.S. Army in the Counterinsurgency Field Manual (pdf file) and in the widely influential work by John Nagl, Learning to Eat Soup with a Knife, counterinsurgency is a multifaceted task of which military response is only one (usually relatively small) part. This is the lesson ignored in Viet Nam, learned in Iraq and currently being relearned (and learned for the first time by Canada) in Afghanistan.

Let's hope we don't forget it in the Indian Ocean

Taking a Step Back

I haven't commented much on the debate swirling around the vast increase in the profitability of the financial sector, and the contribution to this sector to the greater public good. Though I am still searching for comparable Canadian figures, in the U.S., at the onset of the current crisis, financial sector profits had risen from 20% to 40% of all profits in just a few years. It seems likely that Canadian figures are not all that different.

Why, then, do we allocate so much to this sector? The baseline function of any financial sector is to aggregate resources and efficiently allocate these. But more and more, the corporate sector raises its own resources. Or perhaps it is to develop innovative investment vehicles, but we all know how that has turned out.

I think Yglesias hits the nail on the head
Could it really be the case that so many people were naive enough to trust their monies to institutions that were only claiming to have brilliant investment models? Well, it seems to me that it could. And that this would explain why it might make sense for a firm financial firm to pay Larry Summers $5 million a year for a one-day-a-week job. When your company’s underlying product isn’t necessarily sound, it’s important to invest a lot in marketing. Summers is like a celebrity endorsement. This is also a reason, I think, why having gone to a fancy college seems to have been very helpful for getting a job in finance. The firms’ business models very much depend on putt (ing a certain image of themselves forward.
In other words, as I commented earlier, trust in elite MBAs, buttressed by relentless image building and a unified message (invest for the long haul, don't lock in your losses) have led investors to naively trust financial advisors and to stay with them through a devastating downturn. Our lack of financial superstars in Canada is more than offset by our deference to authority -- even incompetent authority.