Thursday, April 2, 2009

Transit Dollars Flow for GTA

Very good news yesterday as the Ontario government announced $9 billion in funding for transit expansion in the GTA. This includes money for the Eglinton Rapid Transit running from Pearson to Kennedy Station, including a portion from Keele to Leslie running underground. Smaller projects include a Vista dedicated bus line along Highway 7, in North York, and extension and upgrading of the existing LRT and an additional light rail transit line on Finch.

It is not clear at this time how this will affect the Sheppard light rail line, and how this changes fit in to the overall Metrolinx plan. But this is very good news for a GTA faced with increasingly inadequate transportation infrastructure.

It is also very intelligent fiscal policy from a Liberal government that usually seems directed by political expediency much more than good public policy sense. Rather than opt for easy fixes such as road infrastructure, the McGuinty government appears to be using the current recession to create the type of infrastructure that will serve the GTA during coming decades of growth.

Friday, March 13, 2009

The Three Stooges Meet Wall Street



I couldn't make this stuff up.

One facet of U.S. efforts to inject life into capital markets is a provision in which, for payment of a fee to the Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation (FDIC), financial institutions can have their bonds backed and thus obtain a coveted AAA rating.

On March 9, the FDIC announced that it would be raising this fee for the largest banks effective April 1. And the banks didn't miss a beat in bellying up to the bar before happy hour ended.

Since that time, the banks, led by Bank of America, Goldman Sachs and General Electric, have issued $29.8 billion in bonds, the second highest weekly amount on record (see Bloomberg). Disappointing, but hardly surprising.

What might raise some eyebrows is the rationales offered by the banks. Goldman Sachs said the sale was
consistent with our long-term funding strategy
While Keycorp opined
[the] bond issue was part of our normal funding strategy and not predicated on any change or proposed change in FDIC structure
These folks make Curly, Larry and Moe look like models of sobriety and probity.

China and the Footsteps of Doom

DEATH, in Terry Pratchett's discworld series, always shows up just when a character faces his or her inevitable end. Yet the character is always surprised and is never prepared for what in retrospect is obvious.

The news today from the New York Times that China is concerned about its holdings of U.S. Treasuries has this flavor. China's own difficulties, its inevitable discomfort with the financial abyss facing the United States and the sheer size of its treasury holdings made this moment inevitable. Yet as Bloomberg notes
President Barack Obama is relying on China to sustain buying of Treasuries amid record amounts of debt sales to fund a $787 billion stimulus package.
Good luck. As the NYT piece notes
. . . much of the Treasury debt China purchased in recent years carries a low interest rate, and would plunge in value if interest rates were to rise sharply in the United States. Some financial experts have warned that measures taken to combat the financial crisis — running large budget deficits and expanding the money supply — may eventually create price inflation, which would lead to higher interest rates.

This puts the Chinese government in a difficult position. The smaller the United States stimulus, the less its borrowing, which could help prevent interest rates from rising. But less government spending in the United States could also mean a slower recovery for the American economy and reduced American demand for Chinese goods.
So where does the U.S. go if the Chinese start to get cold feet? Keep a close eye on treasury yields.

A Damning Indictment of the Finance Crowd



Say what you will about Jon Stewart, last night's interview with CNBC financial guru and future perp walk demonstrator Jim Cramer was as damning an indictment of the financial system and its media sycophants as I have seen during this crisis. Cramer was shown boasting of behavior which, to my non-legal mind, is criminal, and then explaining it away as if he were doing his listeners a favor.

As Stewart said, how many millions of people have been devastated by advice to take the long view with their retirement investments while their erstwhile advisors played fast and loose with their money in this fashion. Bernie Madoff is in jail for being basically stupid. Why run a ponzi scheme when you can do this stuff with impunity.

If we are going to float the banks, here in Canada or in the U.S., then we have a moral obligation as citizens to control their behavior. Obviously they cannot or will not do so themselves. And we had better start to treat the media with the skepticism if not the derision they so richly deserve. They are not telling us the truth.

Thursday, March 12, 2009

Why We Don't Trust Markets -- My Morning Rant

On Tuesday, I had some harsh comments on Citigroup's claim to seemingly miraculous profitability, and the market's uncritical acceptance of the bank's story.

So imagine my chagrin this morning when Bloomberg ran a story that Citigroup executives had pocketed a quick $2.2 million U.S. on the rise resulting from the announcement. And the profits were on shares purchased last week -- i.e. prior to Tuesday's announcement by CEO Vikram Pandit. Surely this is insider trading.

The hapless American taxpayer has watched countless billions thrown at these institutions to avoid financial Armageddon. While this may be necessary, surely the same government that grants these gifts has a moral obligation to investigate, and where necessary prosecute this type of behavior. Bernie Madoff will be a guest of the state for the rest of his life, why not these guys (and they are guys) too.

In my Tuesday comment I said that Citigroup's actions bespoke desperation. I was wrong. If Citigroup executives were long on this trade, one wonders if they had short positions as well when the stock dropped 95% over the past five quarters. In fact, one wonders whether they, or their "masters of the universe" colleagues in general are capable of subordinating self interest to any greater good.

Wednesday, March 11, 2009

Friedman Right on the Money

I am not usually a fan of Thomas Friedman. He seems catch every policy wave at the peak of its trendiness and ride it as far as he can. But his NYT column today is right on the money.

Like Friedman, I have thought for some time that this crisis is much bigger than most realize, and that we are quickly falling behind in our efforts to address it. A faux rally on the market proves nothing. As Friedman notes
It’s always great to see the stock market come back from the dead. But I am deeply worried that our political system doesn’t grasp how much our financial crisis can still undermine everything we want to be as a country. Friends, this is not a test. Economically, this is the big one. This is August 1914. This is the morning after Pearl Harbor. This is 9/12. Yet, in too many ways, we seem to be playing politics as usual.
Canada, in particular, is a small open economy highly dependent on trade. And world trade is in disarray. It is also dependent on two economic engines, the auto sector and oil. The auto sector has collapsed, and unless oil prices recover quickly that sector is in trouble as well. And while our financial sector looks comparatively healthy, the Harper government is hedging its bets to the tune of $200 billion dollars, which certainly raises questions.

In short, we too are staring into the abyss while our political class often appears to be using this crisis for their own gain (see Sen. Elaine McCoy's blog on this). Friedman is right when he says
. . . I wake up every morning hoping to read this story: “President Obama announced today that he had invited the country’s 20 leading bankers, 20 leading industrialists, 20 top market economists and the Democratic and Republican leaders in the House and Senate to join him and his team at Camp David. ‘We will not come down from the mountain until we have forged a common, transparent strategy for getting us out of this banking crisis,’ the president said, as he boarded his helicopter.”
Canada too needs a common and transparent strategy and a much greater sense of urgency.

Tuesday, March 10, 2009

Bernanke on Valuation

In a speech that helped drive markets upward today, Federal Reserve Chairman Ben Bernanke talked, in part, about the problem of valuing assets, a problem that to my mind lies at the very heart of the crisis in the financial system. Long story short, he insisted that valuation is a problem because of the competing issues of procyclicality and transparency -- in plain English, between driving the banks deeper into insolvency and telling the truth. Key passage:
The ongoing move by those who set accounting standards toward requirements for improved disclosure and greater transparency is a positive development that deserves full support. However, determining appropriate valuation methods for illiquid or idiosyncratic assets can be very difficult, to put it mildly. Similarly, there is considerable uncertainty regarding the appropriate levels of loan loss reserves over the cycle. As a result, further review of accounting standards governing valuation and loss provisioning would be useful, and might result in modifications to the accounting rules that reduce their procyclical effects without compromising the goals of disclosure and transparency. Indeed, work is underway on these issues through the Financial Stability Forum, and the results of that work may prove useful for U.S. policymakers.
Surely there are better ways to support credit markets than to fudge the numbers on the real health of the banks. Bernanke seems to suggest this, but is short on details. Moreover, markets are not fooled, as reflected in dropping share prices. And regulators surely understand how a lack of transparency precludes effective supervision. If the emporer is naked, we would save ourselves a lot of trouble if we just told him.

Yglesias on the Banks

Some solid common sense from Matthew Yglesias on bank bailouts, in response to a WSJ piece. Key quote:
You don’t rescue banks by “tak[ing] distressed assets off the balance sheet of Citigroup or other troubled financial institutions.” The problem isn’t the assets, it’s the debts. You can deal with the problem by giving the banks vast sums of money in exchange for their toxic assets but in this case what’s solved the problem isn’t that the assets came off the balance sheet, it’s that the money you gave them got on the balance sheet.
And the key lesson for Canada? You are either paying more than market value for the assets or you aren't doing much to help the banks.

Fair Value or Fantasy

General Electric may be answering the question of what happens when we tell each other the truth about asset values, or absent this, when investors begin to suspect the truth.

Driven mainly by fears about its financial division, GE shares have declined by more than half since early January. The reason, according to a report on Bloomberg today is that the company reports only 2% of its assets at prices that approximate market values. And this, the report notes, strikes fear into investors as
“The notion of having 98 percent opaque and 2 percent valued with clarity is something that by its very nature would make investors nervous,” said Robert Arnott, founder of Research Affiliates LLC, which oversees $30 billion in Newport Beach, California and owned 481,201 GE shares as of Dec. 31. “Having some clarity on what the other 98 percent is worth is valuable.”
Not to be outdone in the understatement sweepstakes, GE spokesman Russell Wilkerson responded
We recognize there is a need and an opportunity to do more to improve disclosure and transparency.
Do tell.

If we are ever going to get to the bottom of this mess, we need to at least begin to tell ourselves the truth about balance sheets, particularly in the financial sector.

This is The Market on Drugs


Citigroup, the troubled U.S. banking giant, is today reporting a profit for the first two months of this year, the first since 2007, with significantly increased revenues. And this, believe it or not, is driving up markets.

Read the fine print!

The "profits" being reported are before provisions for "credit losses, writedowns and additions to loan-loss reserves". In other words, they are not profits at all. Further, those of you not battling significant memory issues might recall that this is the same Citigroup that the U.S. government bailed out to the tune of $45 billion, holds a 36% stake in and is offering to buy tens if not hundreds of billions of toxic assets from. Yet their share price is poised to slip below a dollar.

Yet Bloomberg's headline reads U.S. Stock Futures Rally as Citigroup's Profit Outlook Drives Banks Higher. This isn't reporting, it's cheerleading. It points to a willingness by the business press to trade integrity for the smallest scrap of good news. In other words it smells like desperation.