(ht to Hullabaloos, again)
For those concerned with the health of the Canadian polity, particularly at the federal level, James Travers' column in the Saturday Star is a must read. While lamenting the ethical well-being of society has been a staple of commentary since before Socrates, I nevertheless think Travers is on the mark in noting that ethical conduct in government, and particularly in the office of the prime minister, has fallen on uniquely hard times. And drawing on the work of one of Canada's truly great scholars of Westminster democracies, Donald Savoie, immeasurably strengthens his case.
Yet I wonder if he casts his net wide enough. Not only does the federal government not have a monopoly on abuses of executive power, but I am convinced that this is but a symptom of a much broader problem of ethical malaise that permeates the institutional structure of our society. This is clear with the behavior of various financial institutions of late, but it is, I believe, equally true of corporations more broadly, professions, much of civil society, and even, and perhaps especially the institutional church.
Robert Putnam has written extensively on the role of trust as a social glue that makes collective action possible. In Making Democracy Work: Civic Traditions in Modern Italy, he describes how the erosion of trust affects the capacity for collective action across society. The problem with trust, as Putnam describes it, is that it presents a classic collective action problem; while we benefit from it collectively, we have little incentive to create or strengthen it individually. Where this problem is avoided, or in much rarer instances, resolved, it is most often done through the existence and enforcement of social norms that value ethical behavior. And where these norms break down, no amount of formal enforcement can substitute.
Our dilemma, if Putnam is right, is that trust is a commodity that is extremely fragile and incredibly difficult, if not impossible, to fix once broken. It is therefore in our interest to both hold ourselves to a much higher level of accountability and to do so with those institutions and actors we come in contact with. To paraphrase activist Jennifer Smith at Runesmith, we have to "get off our asses and do something."
Tuesday, April 7, 2009
Time to End the War on Drugs
I just can't give enough credit to Conservative Senator Elaine McCoy. Today, on her always frank and outspoken blog, Hullabaloos, she again speaks truth to power, calling for a revisiting of the decriminalization debate, this at the same time that the increasingly morally challenged Harper government is calling for mandatory minimum sentences for even small amounts of marijuana (surely shameless pandering by a minority government trying to shore up its base). This is, in effect, makes common cause with Libby Davies of the NDP, who is spearheading efforts to defeat Bill C-15.
Davies represents Vancouver's downtown east side, an area as ravaged by drugs as any in Canada. One of her constituents is Dr. Gabor Mate, medical director for a social housing program and manager of Canada's only safe injection site (which the Harper government has attacked relentlessly). Both are passionate and eloquent and I am convinced right in their belief that the war on drugs is a war on our society's most damaged and vulnerable people. Here is a video of a talk Mate gave recently on TVO's Big Ideas

And here is a link to excerpts from a recent speech on this issue by Libby Davies.
Davies represents Vancouver's downtown east side, an area as ravaged by drugs as any in Canada. One of her constituents is Dr. Gabor Mate, medical director for a social housing program and manager of Canada's only safe injection site (which the Harper government has attacked relentlessly). Both are passionate and eloquent and I am convinced right in their belief that the war on drugs is a war on our society's most damaged and vulnerable people. Here is a video of a talk Mate gave recently on TVO's Big Ideas
And here is a link to excerpts from a recent speech on this issue by Libby Davies.
Ineptitude or Malfeasence? -- William K. Black on the Banks
r
As has already been widely commented on, economist William K. Black was interviewed by Bill Moyers on his Bill Moyers' Journal show on Sunday. What Black had to say was damning. A prominent regulator during the Savings and Loan fiasco of the 1980s, he insists that subprime lending, securitization and the insuring of bad debt through insufficiently capitalized credit default swaps were not instances of ineptitude but of malfeasance.
If this is true, and this seems obvious,then, as Black argues, efforts to recapitalize and re-regulate banks are not only misguided, but are a form of willful folly. Those who gamed the system once, by trading off almost unimaginable short term gain for longer term disaster will at least try, and quite likely succeed, in doing so again. The breathtakingly self-serving behavior of financial institutions taking advantage of bailouts and accounting rule changes amply demonstrates this.
Government does not need to 'nationalize' banks to correct their behavior. It has regulatory powers that can be made accountable and effective. And where banks or other financial institutions, whether through circumstance or error, are found to be insolvent by effective accounting standards, they can be put into receivership and reorganized. Our degrees of freedom here are not zero.
As has already been widely commented on, economist William K. Black was interviewed by Bill Moyers on his Bill Moyers' Journal show on Sunday. What Black had to say was damning. A prominent regulator during the Savings and Loan fiasco of the 1980s, he insists that subprime lending, securitization and the insuring of bad debt through insufficiently capitalized credit default swaps were not instances of ineptitude but of malfeasance.
If this is true, and this seems obvious,then, as Black argues, efforts to recapitalize and re-regulate banks are not only misguided, but are a form of willful folly. Those who gamed the system once, by trading off almost unimaginable short term gain for longer term disaster will at least try, and quite likely succeed, in doing so again. The breathtakingly self-serving behavior of financial institutions taking advantage of bailouts and accounting rule changes amply demonstrates this.
Government does not need to 'nationalize' banks to correct their behavior. It has regulatory powers that can be made accountable and effective. And where banks or other financial institutions, whether through circumstance or error, are found to be insolvent by effective accounting standards, they can be put into receivership and reorganized. Our degrees of freedom here are not zero.
At a Crossroad?
It has seemed clear for at least the past couple of months that the global economy is at a point where it may be poised to recover or to slip much further into the abyss. Much has been made, for an against, of a replay of the great depression, and yet much of the debate has seemed like a tiresome repetition of talking points from both sides.
It is clear that the contraction of credit, rapid job loss and staggering market losses mirror the opening months of the depression. Yet it is equally clear that we have policy tools that were not then imaginable, let alone available in 1929-30. And there are what have been termed "green shoots", tantalizing hints of a recovery many believe might now be materializing.
Barry Eichengreen and Kevin O'Rourke yesterday published a brief paper noting that while from an American (or Canadian) perspective, this might look like a typical cyclical recession, from a global perspective, it is anything but. Industrial output, global trade and world stock markets are tracking downward much more quickly than in the opening months of the depression. At the same time, monetary and fiscal responses have been much quicker and much more robust than in the earlier episode.
The question that remains to be answered, for me and for these authors among many others, is whether the latter will offset or counteract the former. The fatuous optimism of Jim Flaherty notwithstanding, this remains to be seen.
It is clear that the contraction of credit, rapid job loss and staggering market losses mirror the opening months of the depression. Yet it is equally clear that we have policy tools that were not then imaginable, let alone available in 1929-30. And there are what have been termed "green shoots", tantalizing hints of a recovery many believe might now be materializing.
Barry Eichengreen and Kevin O'Rourke yesterday published a brief paper noting that while from an American (or Canadian) perspective, this might look like a typical cyclical recession, from a global perspective, it is anything but. Industrial output, global trade and world stock markets are tracking downward much more quickly than in the opening months of the depression. At the same time, monetary and fiscal responses have been much quicker and much more robust than in the earlier episode.
The question that remains to be answered, for me and for these authors among many others, is whether the latter will offset or counteract the former. The fatuous optimism of Jim Flaherty notwithstanding, this remains to be seen.
Labels:
financial crisis,
fiscal policy,
monetary policy
Saturday, April 4, 2009
Inflation???
So let me see.
Now that we have set aside an eye-popping amount of money for the banks, given tax cuts which always benefit the more well-off, ensured that there is plenty of money for businesses to lease equipment, and given billions to the auto sector, inflation is a problem.
How convenient.
You need to search high and low to find more than a handful of (ideologically driven) economists who are not concerned about deflation. Yes, given the level of stimulus applied around the globe since the start of this crisis, and the unprecedented levels of public debt, particularly in the U.S., inflation is not only possible but likely up the road. And we will surely need some of the ample monetary policy room we currently enjoy to control it.
But now?
Japan's experience in the 1990s, and everyone's during the 1930s is that a premature switch in focus to inflation is likely to choke off recovery and prolong what will already be an acutely painful recession. It is difficult to understand this concern now as anything but a reflexive ideological response to unprecedented and admittedly frightening efforts to respond to this crisis
Now that we have set aside an eye-popping amount of money for the banks, given tax cuts which always benefit the more well-off, ensured that there is plenty of money for businesses to lease equipment, and given billions to the auto sector, inflation is a problem.
How convenient.
You need to search high and low to find more than a handful of (ideologically driven) economists who are not concerned about deflation. Yes, given the level of stimulus applied around the globe since the start of this crisis, and the unprecedented levels of public debt, particularly in the U.S., inflation is not only possible but likely up the road. And we will surely need some of the ample monetary policy room we currently enjoy to control it.
But now?
Japan's experience in the 1990s, and everyone's during the 1930s is that a premature switch in focus to inflation is likely to choke off recovery and prolong what will already be an acutely painful recession. It is difficult to understand this concern now as anything but a reflexive ideological response to unprecedented and admittedly frightening efforts to respond to this crisis
Friday, April 3, 2009
NO!!!!!!!!!!!!
This is unbelievable.
In the wake of changes by the FSAB yesterday, relaxing mark to market accounting requirements, and following efforts by the U.S. Fed to entice investors to purchase toxic (though now less so) assets, the Financial Times reports today that many U.S. banks are poised to use public subsidies to purchase these suddenly less toxic assets from their rivals. This did not go unnoticed by legislators:
In the wake of changes by the FSAB yesterday, relaxing mark to market accounting requirements, and following efforts by the U.S. Fed to entice investors to purchase toxic (though now less so) assets, the Financial Times reports today that many U.S. banks are poised to use public subsidies to purchase these suddenly less toxic assets from their rivals. This did not go unnoticed by legislators:
This, of course, beggars the imagination. The AIG bonuses had terrible optics, but ultimately were of little consequence. This is simply a shameless raid on the public treasury by the same folks who brought you the financial meltdown.The plans proved controversial, with critics charging that the government’s public-private partnership - which provide generous loans to investors - are intended to help banks sell, rather than acquire, troubled securities and loans.
Spencer Bachus, the top Republican on the House financial services committee, vowed after being told of the plans by the FT to introduce legislation to stop financial institutions ”gaming the system to reap taxpayer-subsidised windfalls”.
Mr Bachus added it would mark ”a new level of absurdity” if financial institutions were ”colluding to swap assets at inflated prices using taxpayers’ dollars.”
Thursday, April 2, 2009
FASB caves on Mark to Market
In a move that will likely impact accounting standards world-wide, the U.S. Financial Accounting Standards Board acquiesced to the Congress and relaxed mark to market accounting standards. While this is in many ways a very technical issue, its essence is that banks need not write down many of the toxic assets that are at the heart of the current crisis.
Investors are understandably not happy, as this in effect reduces transparency in the very areas where it is most needed. But it allows banks to maintain healthier balance sheets (though surely markets are not fooled by this). In short, it postpones the day of reckoning. As the New York Times' Floyd Norris puts it
Investors are understandably not happy, as this in effect reduces transparency in the very areas where it is most needed. But it allows banks to maintain healthier balance sheets (though surely markets are not fooled by this). In short, it postpones the day of reckoning. As the New York Times' Floyd Norris puts it
If mark-to-market accounting is to blame for the current financial crisis, then the National Weather Service is to blame for Hurricane Katrina; if it hadn’t told us the hurricane hit New Orleans, the city would never have flooded.I am currently trading a twelve year old compact car, in marginal condition, that I originally paid $8500 for. So can I demand, and receive, this amount now?
Next time you hear a banker denounce mark-to-market rules, ask if he runs his business that way. Will he offer you a mortgage loan based on what you think your home should be worth, which you can repay only if you make a lot more money than anyone will pay you? If so, then perhaps the bank should be able to use “Alice in Wonderland” accounting on its own books.
Yes We Can Afford It
Conservative Senator Elaine McCoy's wonderful blog, Hulabaloos, which I cannot plug often enough, has a link to a piece by Oxfam Great Britain's Duncan Green comparing the amounts spent by governments world wide to bail out the financial sector and the costs of alleviating some of the worst global ills.
Many, if not most, have surely felt discomfort at the increasingly fantastical amounts thrown at a financial sector largely responsible for its, and our troubles. What Mr. Green puts in perspective is the almost trivial amounts, in comparison, that would be required to eradicate the worst of poverty and meet a host of other worthy development goals worldwide.
What the past several months have surely done is ended arguments about what we can or cannot afford. We may or may not have the political will or moral vision to do what is decent rather than expedient, but surely never again will be be able to hide behind financial rationalizations. Already we stand shamed as a society for putting the needs of the already wealthy so incredibly far ahead of those most in need.
Many, if not most, have surely felt discomfort at the increasingly fantastical amounts thrown at a financial sector largely responsible for its, and our troubles. What Mr. Green puts in perspective is the almost trivial amounts, in comparison, that would be required to eradicate the worst of poverty and meet a host of other worthy development goals worldwide.
What the past several months have surely done is ended arguments about what we can or cannot afford. We may or may not have the political will or moral vision to do what is decent rather than expedient, but surely never again will be be able to hide behind financial rationalizations. Already we stand shamed as a society for putting the needs of the already wealthy so incredibly far ahead of those most in need.
The Poverty of the Canadian Debate
As I write, I am listening to the U.S. Senate Banking Committee hearings on lessons from the New Deal. Participants include Christine Rohmer of the President's Economic Council, Jamie Galbraith (son of J.K.) and Brad Delong from Berkely and of blogging fame. What a treat!
Where is the Canadian counterpart? We have several excellent schools of public policy and a world class cadre of academic economists. Our two major political parties have fundamental philosophical differences (don't they?) regarding economic policy. And we have a third party (with a substantial academic following) committed to an alternative economic vision. Yet open the paper, turn on the television, or try to search out a public forum on economic policy and it is the same hackneyed arguments we have been hearing for years.
We are in the middle of the greatest economic crisis in several generations. Canadians are being asked to make, and to understand decisions, that will affect them for generations to come. They deserve more than this.
Where is the Canadian counterpart? We have several excellent schools of public policy and a world class cadre of academic economists. Our two major political parties have fundamental philosophical differences (don't they?) regarding economic policy. And we have a third party (with a substantial academic following) committed to an alternative economic vision. Yet open the paper, turn on the television, or try to search out a public forum on economic policy and it is the same hackneyed arguments we have been hearing for years.
We are in the middle of the greatest economic crisis in several generations. Canadians are being asked to make, and to understand decisions, that will affect them for generations to come. They deserve more than this.
Transit Dollars Flow for GTA
Very good news yesterday as the Ontario government announced $9 billion in funding for transit expansion in the GTA. This includes money for the Eglinton Rapid Transit running from Pearson to Kennedy Station, including a portion from Keele to Leslie running underground. Smaller projects include a Vista dedicated bus line along Highway 7, in North York, and extension and upgrading of the existing LRT and an additional light rail transit line on Finch.
It is not clear at this time how this will affect the Sheppard light rail line, and how this changes fit in to the overall Metrolinx plan. But this is very good news for a GTA faced with increasingly inadequate transportation infrastructure.
It is also very intelligent fiscal policy from a Liberal government that usually seems directed by political expediency much more than good public policy sense. Rather than opt for easy fixes such as road infrastructure, the McGuinty government appears to be using the current recession to create the type of infrastructure that will serve the GTA during coming decades of growth.
It is not clear at this time how this will affect the Sheppard light rail line, and how this changes fit in to the overall Metrolinx plan. But this is very good news for a GTA faced with increasingly inadequate transportation infrastructure.
It is also very intelligent fiscal policy from a Liberal government that usually seems directed by political expediency much more than good public policy sense. Rather than opt for easy fixes such as road infrastructure, the McGuinty government appears to be using the current recession to create the type of infrastructure that will serve the GTA during coming decades of growth.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)